We have had a lot of
Pine Siskin visitors recently and the other day I had caught the image of one in flight as it flew away from the Niger seed feeder bag. I was very surprised to see such a spread of yellow at its tail feathers
and I enlarged the photo to get a better view. As I studied the picture of this surprisingly colourful
male Pine Siskin I kept thinking =
female American Redstart? So I just had to go to my photo archives and check out my hunch to see how close the colour patterning between these two species was.
Pine Siskins and American Redstarts are of a similar size, the Siskin being 5' in length and the Redstart 5.25", and as I placed the photos side by side I was pleased to see the similarity I had noticed when first sighting the Pine Siskin.
It was a nice breath of summer to have been reminded of this litte summer warbler, an American Redstart, on such a cold wintry day.
We have had a lot of Pine Siskin visitors recently and the other day I had caught the image of one in flight as it flew away from the Niger seed feeder bag. I was very surprised to see such a spread of yellow at its tail feathers 
and I enlarged the photo to get a better view. As I studied the picture of this surprisingly colourful male Pine Siskin I kept thinking = female American Redstart? So I just had to go to my photo archives and check out my hunch to see how close the colour patterning between these two species was.
Pine Siskins and American Redstarts are of a similar size, the Siskin being 5' in length and the Redstart 5.25", and as I placed the photos side by side I was pleased to see the similarity I had noticed when first sighting the Pine Siskin.
It was a nice breath of summer to have been reminded of this litte summer warbler, an American Redstart, on such a cold wintry day.
What a keen observation.I had never seen the similarities,but it is quite evident,as you point out.I will be looking at the Siskins more closely now.Thanks.
ReplyDeleteBlessings,Ruth
Not being that familiar with birds I probably would not have notice the difference. Love your shots, especially the one in fight.
ReplyDeleteI've never noticed that yellow on the pine siskins tail....never see it in flight like this! That is very interesting to see the two together. I've never seen a Redstart so I can't compare.
ReplyDeleteGood observations and keen sleuthing! Love how you can magnify parts of the photo. Great stuff!!
ReplyDeleteGood eye! I am too new at birding and would not have picked up on this similarity...so it was very nice to read your post and learn. Don't you love it when you capture a surprise on your camera, like a bird in flight or in an interesting pose!! Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteThanks for pointing out the difference to this bird lover.
ReplyDeleteGreat photos.
I have never seen a Pine Siskin but have seen the American Redstart when they migrate through. I guess I would have a hard time telling which is which.
ReplyDeleteI seldom notice that much yellow on the Pine Siskins here. Great pictures and comparisons. At least they don't appear in the same season to confuse me.
ReplyDeleteI could never understand how people got hooked into bird watching, but after seeing all of your beautiful photos on your blog...I now understand.
ReplyDeleteThis is great Ann..I love to learn something new..I almost missed the siskins with the goldfinch. You have to watch carefully...
ReplyDeleteI never would have picked up on the Redstart. I have so many Siskins this year like never before. I was hoping the Redpolls would show up with them, but no such luck. Super shots Ann.
ReplyDeleteB.
I love these photos of the pine siskins. Beautifully captured.
ReplyDelete